Case Report
Volume 2 Issue 1 - 2020
Flexion-distraction Fracture of the Pelvis: Review of the Literature and a Conceptual Classification
1MBChB; FC Orth (SA); MMED Orth, Pelvic and Acetabular Trauma Fellow, Head: Arthroplasty Unit Greys Tertiary Hospital, University of KwaZulu Natal, South Africa
2MBChB, senior orthopaedic Registrarm, University of the Witwatersrand
3Head of Clinical Unit: Orthopaedic Trauma, Groote Schuur Hospital, University of Cape Town, President: South African Orthopaedic Trauma Society, Executive Committee Member: AO Trauma South Africa
4MBBCh. FCS (SA) Orth, Director: Cape Orthopaedic Trauma Group, Country Council Chairman: AO Trauma South Africa, Chairman: Medical Advisory Committee. Life Orthopaedic & Vincent Palloti Hospital
2MBChB, senior orthopaedic Registrarm, University of the Witwatersrand
3Head of Clinical Unit: Orthopaedic Trauma, Groote Schuur Hospital, University of Cape Town, President: South African Orthopaedic Trauma Society, Executive Committee Member: AO Trauma South Africa
4MBBCh. FCS (SA) Orth, Director: Cape Orthopaedic Trauma Group, Country Council Chairman: AO Trauma South Africa, Chairman: Medical Advisory Committee. Life Orthopaedic & Vincent Palloti Hospital
*Corresponding Author: Duma MTN, MBChB; FC Orth (SA); MMED Orth, Pelvic and Acetabular Trauma Fellow, Head: Arthroplasty Unit Greys Tertiary Hospital, University of KwaZulu Natal, South Africa.
Received: July 16, 2020; Published: July 25, 2020
Abstract
We present a rare injury pattern of the pelvis that has not been published prior to this report in the literature. We describe in detail the injury sustained by a young male who was involved in a motor vehicle collision and suffered multiple injuries, including blunt head and chest trauma; pelvic and as well as long bone fractures. The injury pattern did not fall into the currently available classification systems and thus motivated us to design a classification system and suggest an approach to management as we have successfully managed our case.
Keywords: Pelvis; Classification; Flexion-distraction
Abbreviations: ICU= Intensive care unit; ATLS= Advanced trauma life support; MVC = motor vehicle collision
Introduction
Pelvic fractures make up 16% of all major trauma. This represents high energy trauma associated with a high mortality rate (31%). Majority of these fractures are classified using the common classification systems, namely Young and Burgess or Tile classification. Some fracture patterns however do not fit into any fracture classification system. We present a rare case of a flexion-distraction fracture of the pelvis with a proposed conceptual classification.
Case
A 26 year old male presented to the emergency department following a head-on high energy motor-vehicle collision (MVC). He was a restrained driver. He sustained multiple injuries including the following: intra-peritoneal urinary bladder rupture, blunt renal and hepatic trauma, left mid-shaft femur fracture, bilateral ankle fractures (open fracture on the right), right talus fracture and lastly a bilateral symmetric transverse fracture of the iliac wings also involving the sacrum. This was associated with a Morel-lavalleé lesion, which was debrided and had a washout with vancomycin powder mixed in saline wash.
He had sensory paraesthesia in the S2-S5 region. Clinically motor function of upper and lower limbs was unaffected. Debridement and fixation of the open ankle injury was undertaken with subsequent wound closure in the second sitting. He also underwent an ante-grade intra-medullary femur nail for the left femur. He required a long stay in ICU for improved ventilation. The pelvic fracture was treated surgically without adverse events by the first author*using a posterior approach to the pelvis through paramedian incisions plus internal fixation. At six months follow up, the patient was fully mobile and pain-free from the pelvic fracture.
Discussion
The severity of this fracture pattern and the neurological risk it poses warrants its inclusion in existing classification systems. However this being a rare injury pattern the currently available classification systems do not account for this particular injury pattern. Having managed our patient and his injury pattern inspired us to design a conceptual classification {Figure 1} for this fracture pattern as well as a proposed treatment algorithm. The growth plate injury addition in the conceptual classification is based on an injury pattern observed in a child treated with a pelvic fracture that involved the posterior ring {Figure 2}. This child was involved in a MVC and sustained a femoral artery injury resulting in hip disarticulation after a delayed hospital presentation. She also sustained a pelvis injury involving the Sacroiliac Joint and Iliac apophysis which was treated with threaded sacroiliac rods {ITS. Austria} and Kwire fixation. We have also not seen her injury pattern described in the literature as well.
(Black) type 1= growth plate
A: non-displaced; observe and counsel for possible growth disturbance & asymmetric pelvis.
B- Displaced= reduce and fix.
A: non-displaced; observe and counsel for possible growth disturbance & asymmetric pelvis.
B- Displaced= reduce and fix.
(Green) type 2= Bilateral Crescent injuries=> ORIF to stabilise & mobilise early. LC 2 screws Vs Posterior fixation. Static films = may show non-displaced injury, however since it’s a posterior lesion ORIF recommended.
(Red) type 3 = (as with type 2 - spinopelvic dissociation =>ORIF is recommended:
A: no Neurology; therefore protect neurology through ORIF.
B: Neurological fallout; MRI (Identify lesion and Prognosticate)+ Neurosurgeon/ Spine Surgeon (spinal decompression + intra-op Neuromonitoring + posterior fixation +/- SpinoPelvic fixation where the skillset is available)
A: no Neurology; therefore protect neurology through ORIF.
B: Neurological fallout; MRI (Identify lesion and Prognosticate)+ Neurosurgeon/ Spine Surgeon (spinal decompression + intra-op Neuromonitoring + posterior fixation +/- SpinoPelvic fixation where the skillset is available)
14year girl involved in MVA sustained vascular injury and presented too late for limb salvage and was disarticulated at the hip joint ipsilateral to the iliac crest pelvic injury and SacroILiac joint injury. She had staged fixation for some of her injuries as she recovered in ICU. Her injury patter n assisted in conceptualising the classification.
Conclusion
Symmetrical bilateral transverse fracture of the pelvis is an extremely rare injury. This fracture does not fit into any existing classification system. This is associated with high energy trauma and management should focus on life-threatening injuries first. On the basis of the limited available literature, the fracture is associated with a relatively good prognosis and a good functional outcome can be expected. We present the first conceptual classification to help guide surgeons’ clinical decision making. Understanding that what is rare now may not be in the future we hope to have added value to the body of science.
Acknowledgments
All the authors contributed to the publication of this work. The patient also gave consent to write on the findings of his injury as well as publish the relevant images to advance science and improve future patient care.
All the authors contributed to the publication of this work. The patient also gave consent to write on the findings of his injury as well as publish the relevant images to advance science and improve future patient care.
References
- Palmcrantz J, Hardcastle T, Naidoo S, Muckart D. (2012). Pelvic fractures at a New Level 1 Trauma Centre: Who Dies from pelvic trauma? The Inkosi Albert Luthuli Central Hospital Experience. Orthopaedic Surgery. 4:216-221.
- Andrew Gray, Henry Chandler, Omar Sabri. (2018). Pelvic ring injuries: classification and treatment. Orthopaedics and Trauma. Volume 32, Issue 2 80-90.
- Ofiram E, Mosheiff R, Liebergall M. (2002). Symmetric Bilateral Transverse Fracture of the Iliac Wings: Chance Fracture of the Pelvis. Journal of Orthopaedic Trauma. Volume 16(8), September 605-607.
- Chance G. (1948). Note on a type of flexion fracture of the spine. Br J Radiol 21:452-453.
- Greenbaum E, Rolston L. (1971). Flexion Fracture of the Pelvis Due to a Lap-Type Seat Belt. Radiology 100:531-532.
- Fabbri F. (1970). Unusual case of bilateral symmetric transverse fracture of the osso illi: Chir Organi Mov 59:285-290.
- Banerjee A. (1989). Seat belts and injury patterns: evolution and present perspectives. Postgraduate Medical Journal 65, 199 – 204.
- Joshua R. Langford, MD Andrew R. Burgess, MD Frank A. Liporace, MD George J. Haidukewych, MD. (2013). Pelvic Fractures: Part 1. Evaluation, Classification, and Resuscitation. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 21: 448-457.
- International Comprehensive Classification of Fractures and Dislocations Committee. (2018). Fracture and Dislocation Classification Compendium 2018. J Orthop Trauma Vol. 32, Number 1 Supplement, January.
Citation: Duma MTN, Ntombela PI, S Maqungo and B Bernstein. (2020). Flexion-distraction Fracture of the Pelvis: Review of the Literature and a Conceptual Classification. Journal of Orthopaedic and Trauma Care 2(1). DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.3963503
Copyright: © 2020 Duma MTN. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.